PGA Championship vs The Masters: 7 Key Differences Explained

Curious about the differences between the PGA Championship and The Masters? Both are prestigious events in professional golf, but they have distinct histories, traditions, and formats. 

In this article, we’ll break down the 7 key differences that set these two tournaments apart, helping you understand what makes each of them unique. Keep reading to discover which one stands out to you! 

Without further ado, let’s get started…

 1. Tournament History and Origins

When it comes to golf’s major tournaments, both the Masters and the PGA Championship carry a rich history. But their origins and evolution show just how different these two events are.

Here are some interesting facts about the rich history of these two tournaments: 

The Masters

The Masters Tournament, one of the most prestigious events in the golfing world, was established in 1934. It is held annually at Augusta National Golf Club in Augusta, Georgia. 

The tournament was founded by two key figures in golf history: Bobby Jones(a legendary amateur golfer) and Clifford Roberts(a financier). Together, they created the event with a vision of bringing together the best golfers to compete at one of the most beautiful courses in the world.

• Location: Augusta National Golf Club, Georgia, USA.
• Established: 1934 
• Founders: Bobby Jones and Clifford Roberts 
• Significance: Known for its traditions, iconic holes, and the coveted Green Jacket awarded to the winner. 

Over the years, The Masters has developed a rich tradition, with the winner receiving the famous Green Jacket. It is one of the four major championships in professional golf, often regarded as the most prestigious due to its exclusivity and iconic status in the sport.

 PGA Championship

The PGA Championship, founded in 1916, is the oldest of the four major championships in golf. It was initially conceived as a match play event by the PGA of America, aimed at bringing together the best professionals in the game. However, in 1958, the event transitioned to a stroke-play format, which remains in place today.

• Location: Rotates annually among different top courses across the USA 
• Established: 1916 
• Founder: PGA of America 
• Format Change: Transitioned from match play to stroke play in 1958 

While not as steeped in the same traditions as The Masters, the PGA Championship has maintained its status as one of the key events in professional golf, with a reputation for showcasing fierce competition and a wide range of talent from around the world. 

Unlike The Masters, it is held at various prestigious courses across the United States each year, adding a dynamic challenge to the event.

2. Course and Location

When it comes to the venues for these two iconic tournaments, the contrast is clear. While both the PGA Championship and The Masters feature world-class competition, the courses themselves add unique dimensions to the tournaments, influencing the gameplay, strategies, and overall atmosphere. 

Let’s take a closer look at how the locations of these events set them apart.

The Masters: 

The Masters Tournament is always held at the same legendary venue, Augusta National Golf Club. This course, located in Augusta, Georgia, is famous for its lush fairways, manicured greens, and breathtaking beauty. 

Furthermore, Augusta National is often considered the most iconic golf course in the world, with its challenging layout and signature holes, such as the 12th hole at Amen Corner, where many a tournament has been decided.

• Location: Augusta National Golf Club, Augusta, Georgia.
• Famous Holes: Amen Corner (holes 11, 12, 13) 
• Course Features: Pristine conditions, immaculate fairways, and exclusive access. 

The consistency of having every Masters at Augusta contributes to the tournament’s aura of tradition and prestige, making it a unique spectacle in the golfing world.

PGA Championship: 

In contrast, the PGA Championship is hosted at different golf courses across the United States every year. This rotation adds variety to the tournament, providing different challenges and course layouts for players. 

From the difficult, undulating greens of Bethpage Black in New York to the wide-open layouts of Southern Hills in Oklahoma, each venue offers a new set of obstacles and strategic demands for the golfers.

• Location: Rotates annually among top courses across the U.S. 
• Course Variety: From open layouts to tight, tricky layouts.
• Challenges: Offers a diverse set of challenges with each new course, testing players in different ways.

The changing venues of the PGA Championship offer players the opportunity to showcase their versatility, as they adapt to new environments and strategies each year. This dynamic approach contrasts sharply with the stability and familiarity of Augusta.

3. Field Size and Qualification

One of the most noticeable differences between The Masters and the PGA Championship is the size and makeup of the player field. These differences impact not only who gets to compete, but also the level of exclusivity and diversity in the competition. 

The Masters: 

The Masters is known for its selective and exclusive field. Unlike other majors, participation is by invitation only, and the tournament typically hosts around 90 players, making it the smallest field among the four majors.

Players qualify through a mix of criteria, including: 

• Past Masters champions (lifetime exemption). 
• Winners of other major championships (within the last five years).
• Top finishers from the previous year’s Masters.
• Top amateurs, including winners of the U.S. Amateur and British Amateur Championships.
• Players ranked in the top 50 of the Official World Golf Ranking.

This selectiveness adds to the tournament’s prestige and creates a highly competitive atmosphere among elite players. 

PGA Championship: 

In contrast, the PGA Championship features a much larger field, with up to 156 players competing each year. It welcomes a broader spectrum of talent, including many of the world’s top-ranked professionals and notable club professionals.

Key qualification paths include:

• All former PGA Championship winners (lifetime exemption).
• Winners of the other three majors within the past five years.
• Top 70 players from the PGA Tour money list.
• Members of recent Ryder Cup teams.
• 20 club professionals who earn their place through the PGA Professional Championship.

This wider field brings more diversity and depth to the competition, showcasing not only top-tier pros but also the best of grassroots golf talent. The inclusion of club professionals reflects the PGA of America’s mission to promote the game at all levels.

4. Traditions and Atmosphere

The Masters and the PGA Championship not only differ in their format and field size, but their atmospheres and traditions are what truly set them apart. Each tournament presents a unique experience, giving fans and players alike something distinct to look forward to. 

The Masters: 

The Masters is celebrated for its rich traditions, many of which have become synonymous with the event itself. The tournament’s atmosphere is built on its exclusive and ceremonial nature, making it a standout among golf’s major championships.

• The Green Jacket Ceremony: The most famous tradition of all, where the winner is awarded the iconic Green Jacket, which is then ceremonially placed on their shoulders. This moment is one of the most prestigious in all of sport and symbolizes the winner’s entry into a special club of champions. 
• Champions Dinner: Held on the Tuesday before the tournament begins, this private event brings together past Masters champions. The previous year’s winner selects the menu, and it becomes a celebration of golf history and camaraderie. This dinner is more than a meal; it is a gathering of legends. 
• Par-3 Contest: A lighthearted event held the day before the tournament officially starts. Featuring a 9-hole par-3 course, this contest is a fan favorite as it gives players a chance to unwind and enjoy the company of their families, often with humorous and heartwarming moments.
  

The Masters’ commitment to maintaining these traditions adds to its mystique and charm, making it one of the most anticipated events in the golfing world. 

PGA Championship: 

On the other hand, the PGA Championship is less focused on ceremonial aspects and more on the competitive side of the sport. The atmosphere here is designed to showcase the strength of the field and the difficulties presented by the courses.

Key characteristics of the PGA Championship’s atmosphere include:

• Pure Focus on Competition: Without any ceremonial distractions, the attention stays on who’s playing the best golf. Every player is there to win, and the atmosphere reflects that intensity. 
• Strong Field & Tough Setups: The PGA Championship consistently draws one of the strongest fields in professional golf. Course setups tend to push players to their limits with thick rough, fast greens, and strategic layouts. 
• More Accessible Energy: The tournament is known for having a slightly more relaxed and fan-friendly vibe compared to the Masters, making it popular among a broader audience.  

While the PGA Championship doesn’t have the same fanfare as The Masters, its focus on the game’s competitive spirit and its unpredictable, challenging courses offer a different yet equally exciting experience for fans and players alike.

5. Timing and Placement in the Golf Calendar

The timing of a golf tournament can significantly influence the mood and build-up to the event. The Masters and PGA Championship are both major tournaments, but they occupy distinct spots in the golf calendar, which helps shape their respective atmospheres and expectations.

The Masters: 

The Masters is the first major of the golf season, traditionally held in early April. This timing plays a critical role in setting the tone for the entire year, with players aiming to start their season strong at Augusta National.

• When: Held in early April, marking the beginning of the major championship calendar. 
• Significance: As the first major, it draws significant attention, as golfers look to establish themselves early in the season. The tournament sets the stage for the rest of the year, creating momentum for the players who perform well here. 
• Season Kickoff: The Masters kicks off the high-stakes phase of the golfing year and is an event where golfers often perform at their best, setting expectations for their future success. 

With the excitement of a new season, The Masters carries the added pressure of being the first big test of the year. For many, winning this prestigious event is the ideal way to start their season, adding extra significance to every round. 

PGA Championship: 

Traditionally held in May, the PGA Championship serves as the second major of the year, following The Masters. By this time, the season is in full swing, and players have had a chance to establish their form, with the PGA providing another opportunity to claim a major title.

• When: Traditionally scheduled for May, placing it just after The Masters. 
• Significance: As the second major, the PGA Championship often serves as a midpoint in the major tournament season. By the time this event rolls around, the storylines for the year are beginning to form, and golfers are looking to solidify their position in the race for the year’s top honors. 
• Strategic Importance: Players use this tournament to position themselves for the remaining majors, as a win at the PGA can greatly impact a golfer’s confidence and standing for the rest of the year. 

While The Masters creates an early-season buzz, the PGA Championship holds a unique place as the next major challenge for players, marking a critical moment in the annual golf schedule.

6. Prestige and Global Recognition

The prestige of a golf tournament often defines its place in the sport’s history, and both The Masters and the PGA Championship hold significant status in the world of golf. However, the perception of their prestige and the level of global recognition they command differ slightly due to their unique characteristics. 

The Masters: 

The Masters is widely regarded as the most prestigious of all the golf majors. Its exclusivity, coupled with its iconic venue and longstanding traditions, elevates it above many other tournaments in the eyes of players and fans alike.

• Exclusivity: The Masters is an invitation-only event with a field of fewer than 100 players, which adds an air of exclusivity that’s unmatched in the golfing world. 
• Iconic Venue: Augusta National Golf Club is synonymous with the tournament itself. The lush fairways, historic holes, and the famous Green Jacket all contribute to a sense of prestige and tradition that’s difficult to replicate elsewhere. 
• Traditions and Legacy: The tournament is steeped in rituals that enhance its grandeur, from the Champions Dinner to the Green Jacket ceremony, making it a symbolic event that transcends sports. 
• Global Recognition: The Masters is not only a seasonal kickoff for golf but also a global spectacle, watched by millions worldwide, ensuring its position at the forefront of global golf culture. 

Due to these factors, The Masters is often considered the crown jewel of golf, with its place in history secured by its commitment to excellence and tradition. 

PGA Championship: 

While still one of the four major tournaments in golf, the PGA Championship is often seen as slightly less prestigious compared to The Masters and the U.S. Open. This is largely due to its rotating venues, lack of a singular, iconic course like Augusta, and a somewhat less exclusive field.

• Strong Field: The PGA Championship is respected for its strong, diverse field, which includes both professional golfers and club professionals who qualify through the PGA Professional Championship. This mix ensures the event is highly competitive, but it also results in a less focused atmosphere compared to The Masters. 
• Competitive Play: The tournament’s emphasis is firmly placed on competition, and its strong field showcases many of the world’s best golfers, but it doesn’t have the same legacy or tradition attached to it. 
• Global Recognition: While respected worldwide, the PGA Championship’s recognition can be overshadowed by other majors, particularly The Masters, due to the latter’s distinct identity and long-standing popularity. 

Though the PGA Championship holds a prestigious spot in the golf calendar, it’s often regarded as a major tournament that doesn’t carry the same level of global prestige as The Masters, due to its more fluid format and less iconic venue.

7. Impact on Player Careers

The impact of winning either The Masters or the PGA Championship extends far beyond the immediate glory. Both tournaments provide winners with significant career benefits, offering exemptions, invitations, and other perks that can shape the trajectory of a player’s career. 

The Masters: 

Winning The Masters has a lasting effect on a player’s career, providing a lifetime invitation to the tournament, along with valuable exemptions for other major tournaments.

• Lifetime Invitation to The Masters: One of the most coveted prizes in golf, the winner of The Masters is invited back to compete at Augusta National for the rest of their life. This ongoing presence at one of golf’s most iconic events ensures that players can continue to participate in a prestigious tournament, regardless of their future form. 
• Five-Year Exemption to Other Majors: In addition to the Masters invite, the winner earns a five-year exemption to the U.S. Open, British Open, and PGA Championship. This gives players the opportunity to continue competing in the world’s biggest tournaments without having to qualify, providing a significant boost to their career. 
• Endorsements and Global Recognition: Winning The Masters often leads to increased visibility and endorsement opportunities. Players become household names, and the prestige of Augusta National adds weight to their career accomplishments. 

The Masters is not just a victory for the year; it has a long-lasting impact, ensuring that the winner’s career remains highlighted by the tournament’s legacy. 

PGA Championship: 

The PGA Championship also offers major benefits to its winner, particularly in the form of a five-year exemption and a lifetime invitation to future editions of the tournament.

• Five-Year Exemption to Other Majors: Like The Masters, the winner of the PGA Championship gains a five-year exemption to the U.S. Open, British Open, and The Masters. This allows the player to continue their career with reduced qualification pressure for the upcoming major events. 
• Lifetime Invitation to the PGA Championship: Unlike The Masters, which offers a lifetime invitation only to its own tournament, the PGA Championship gives the winner a lifetime pass to compete in future PGA Championships. This is a significant benefit for players who enjoy the course rotation and the opportunity to compete annually in a major. 
• Recognition and Career Momentum: Winning the PGA Championship provides career momentum and is a key achievement for any player. It may not have the same global impact as a Masters win, but it still places a player in an elite group of champions, with the prize leading to potential sponsorships and career opportunities. 

While the PGA Championship’s impact on a player’s career is not as exclusive as The Masters, it still plays a major role in securing future opportunities and ensuring a lasting legacy within the sport.

Final Thoughts

Both The Masters and the PGA Championship are monumental events in the golfing world, each holding unique qualities that contribute to their status as major tournaments. 

• The Masters is defined by its prestigious history, iconic Augusta National Golf Club, and exclusive traditions that give it an air of mystique and unrivaled prestige. 
• In contrast, the PGA Championship offers a dynamic and competitive environment, with varying courses each year and a larger, more diverse field that showcases a broad spectrum of golfing talent. 

While The Masters captivates with its legacy and traditions, the PGA Championship stands out for its focus on intense competition and accessibility. 

Ultimately, both tournaments significantly impact a player’s career, providing not only accolades and exemptions but also long-term recognition in the world of golf. Each tournament has its own special allure, making them both integral to the golfing calendar and essential to understanding the sport’s rich history.

Key Takeaways

• The Masters was founded in 1934 at Augusta National Golf Club and is known for its exclusivity and tradition, while the PGA Championship began in 1916 and originally featured a match play format before switching to stroke play in 1958.
• The Masters is always played at the iconic Augusta National in Georgia, enhancing its legacy. In contrast, the PGA Championship rotates venues annually across top golf courses in the U.S., offering different course challenges each year.
• The Masters hosts a smaller, invitation-only field of about 90 elite players, whereas the PGA Championship features a much larger and more diverse field of up to 156 players, including club professionals.
• The Masters is steeped in tradition, from the Green Jacket ceremony to the Champions Dinner and the Par-3 Contest. The PGA Championship focuses more on pure competition and offers a more relaxed, fan-friendly atmosphere.
• The Masters is the first major of the year (April), kicking off the major season, while the PGA Championship follows in May, playing a pivotal mid-season role in shaping the year’s golf narrative.
• The Masters is often viewed as the most prestigious major due to its exclusivity, traditions, and iconic venue. The PGA Championship, while also a major, is more celebrated for its deep, competitive field.
• Augusta National’s consistent setup rewards experience and course knowledge. Meanwhile, the PGA Championship courses vary each year, testing players’ adaptability across different layouts and conditions.
• The Masters offers a more exclusive, tradition-focused experience for viewers, whereas the PGA Championship provides a broader, more accessible vibe, appealing to casual fans and serious golf enthusiasts alike.
• Winning The Masters often defines a golfer’s legacy and guarantees instant fame due to its historical weight. A PGA Championship win is highly respected, especially for those seeking to prove themselves against a deep field.
• The Green Jacket at The Masters has become one of the most iconic symbols in sports. The PGA Championship, while not tied to a specific symbolic prize, represents grit, diversity, and professional excellence in golf. 

FAQs