What is a Mulligan in Golf? Rules and Etiquette Explained

If you’re new to golf or just looking to brush up on the game’s rules and etiquette, you’ve probably heard the term “mulligan” thrown around. But what exactly does it mean, and when is it appropriate to use? Don’t worry. We’ve got you covered with this article. 

In this article, we’ll explain the concept of a mulligan in golf, including when it’s allowed, the common rules that apply, and the etiquette you should follow. Whether you’re teeing off for the first time or refining your skills, understanding the mulligan can add a fun and forgiving twist to your game. 

So, without further ado, let’s read on to learn more!

What is a Mulligan in Golf?

A mulligan is a term used in golf to refer to a “do-over” shot. Essentially, it’s the opportunity to replay a shot without counting it as a penalty. The mulligan is not an official rule of golf, but it’s widely practiced in informal and casual settings. 

In simple terms, if a golfer hits a bad shot, they may take a mulligan, re-hit the shot, and continue without any penalty.

Context of its use:

• Casual Play: Mulligans are most commonly used in friendly, non-competitive rounds of golf. Golfers often agree to allow one or two mulligans per round to make the game more enjoyable and less frustrating. It’s a way to relieve the pressure of having a bad shot without affecting the overall score.
• Competitive Play: In official competitions, mulligans are generally not allowed. The rules of golf require that every shot be counted, and no redo opportunities are granted. This ensures a level playing field where every golfer is held to the same standards and rules.

So, while a mulligan is an unofficial, informal aspect of the game, it can make rounds more enjoyable, especially for beginners or casual golfers who might find the pressure of perfect shots overwhelming. However, in competitive play, golfers need to be prepared to accept every shot as part of their game.

The Origins of the Term Mulligan Regard To Golf

The origins of the term “mulligan” in golf are somewhat mysterious, with several popular theories suggesting how it may have come into common use. While there’s no definitive answer, these theories give an intriguing look at the historical background of this unique term.

1. The David Mulligan Theory: One of the most widely accepted explanations is linked to a Canadian golfer named David Bernard Mulligan, who played in the 1920s and 1930s. The story goes that Mulligan would often take an extra shot on the first tee if his initial attempt was poor. His friends at Winged Foot Golf Club in New York jokingly called this extra shot a “Mulligan” after him, and the name stuck.
2. The Hotel Mulligan Theory: Another theory ties the origin of “mulligan” to David Mulligan’s role as a hotel manager in Montreal. According to this story, he would drive his friends to the golf course, enduring a bumpy, stressful ride. As a sort of reward or compensation for the effort, he was allowed an extra shot, which became known as a “mulligan.”
3. The John A. “Buddy” Mulligan Theory: In a separate account, John A. “Buddy” Mulligan, a prominent amateur golfer, was said to have popularized the term in the 1930s. Some believe that his group of friends coined “mulligan” for their extra shot, and it eventually spread among golfers.

Regardless of its exact origin, “mulligan” has become one of golf’s most recognized terms, embodying the spirit of second chances. Whether due to a quirky tradition at a local club or a memorable golfer’s name, the “mulligan” offers players a light-hearted escape from the game’s usual rigor.

Rules Surrounding Mulligans

When it comes to using mulligans in golf, there are some informal rules and guidelines that most players follow to keep things fair and enjoyable in casual play. Here’s a look at the typical rules surrounding mulligans:

1. General Rules for Using Mulligans in Casual Play: Since mulligans aren’t recognized by official golf rules, they’re typically only used in informal rounds among friends. Mulligans are often allowed on the first tee shot or early in the round to give players a chance to warm up. If a mulligan is taken, the player re-hits the shot and disregards the original one, which isn’t counted toward their score.
2. Agreement Among Players Before the Round: To avoid misunderstandings, it’s best to reach an agreement on mulligan rules before starting the round. Players should discuss whether mulligans will be allowed, when they can be taken, and if any specific limitations apply. This way, everyone has a clear understanding of the ground rules and can enjoy the game without confusion.
3. Limitations on the Number of Mulligans Allowed: Typically, players limit the number of mulligans to one or two per round to maintain a balance between fun and fairness. Allowing unlimited mulligans could undermine the challenge of the game, so it’s customary to keep mulligans to a minimum. Many players allow one mulligan per nine holes or just a single mulligan for the entire round, often called a “breakfast ball” if taken on the first hole.

These informal rules help create a consistent and enjoyable experience for all players, allowing everyone to benefit from a do-over without compromising the spirit of the game. 

Types of Mulligans

In casual golf, players sometimes use different types of mulligans to add flexibility and fun to the game. Here are two common types:

1. Must Mulligan: 

This type of mulligan requires a mandatory retake of a shot. When a “must mulligan” is agreed upon, the player has no choice but to replay the shot, even if the second attempt might not be any better than the first! 

This type is typically used for specific situations where players agree that a particularly bad shot needs a redo to keep the game flowing smoothly. It’s a lighthearted approach that keeps the mood relaxed, especially for newer players.

2. Provisional Mulligan: 

A provisional mulligan offers a choice. In this scenario, a player can choose between keeping their first shot or replacing it with the mulligan shot. If the second attempt is worse, the player has the option to go with the original shot. 

This type of mulligan adds flexibility but still encourages players to give each shot their best effort, knowing they can fall back on their first attempt if needed.

These types of mulligans allow golfers to enjoy their game with some leeway, while still promoting improvement and strategic thinking about each shot.

When to Use a Mulligan

Mulligans are often used in golf to help players recover from poor shots, but they’re typically reserved for specific situations to keep the game fair and fun. Here are some common scenarios and guidelines for using a mulligan:

1. Common Scenarios for Taking a Mulligan:

• First Tee Shot (“Breakfast Ball”): Many casual golfers allow a mulligan on the first tee if they’re feeling nervous or not fully warmed up. Known as a “breakfast ball,” this mulligan gives players a chance to start their round on a positive note.
• Severely Poor Shots: If a shot goes wildly off-target(like hitting into the trees or into a water hazard) players may take a mulligan to avoid losing their ball or struggling through a challenging lie. This usage, however, is usually limited to once or twice in a round to prevent overuse.
• Unexpected Conditions: Sometimes, an uncontrollable factor, such as a sudden noise or gust of wind, disrupts a shot. In these cases, some players might agree to a mulligan, especially if it’s something that affected everyone’s concentration.

2. Guidelines for Appropriate Use During a Round:

• Agree Beforehand: Players should agree on any mulligan rules before the round begins. This avoids disputes and ensures everyone has the same understanding.
• Limit Mulligans to One or Two: For fairness and enjoyment, it’s typical to allow no more than one or two mulligans per round. Allowing unlimited mulligans can take away the challenge and integrity of the game.
• Use Only When Necessary: Mulligans are meant to add enjoyment, not to serve as a constant fallback. Players should aim to use mulligans sparingly and save them for the most challenging or frustrating situations.

By following these guidelines, players can enjoy the flexibility of mulligans while keeping the round fair and enjoyable for everyone.

Etiquette of Taking a Mulligan

Taking a mulligan in golf requires good etiquette to ensure that it’s a positive experience for everyone involved. Here are some key aspects of mulligan etiquette to keep in mind:

1. Importance of Communication with Playing Partners: 

Before taking a mulligan, it’s courteous to communicate with your playing partners. Mulligans are not part of the official rules, so it’s essential to have agreement from everyone in the group about when and how they’re allowed. 

Furthermore, checking in with your group helps avoid misunderstandings and ensures everyone is on the same page.

2. Recommendations for Maintaining Pace of Play: 

Mulligans should be taken quickly to keep the game moving smoothly. If you decide to take a mulligan, don’t overthink the redo shot(prepare and hit promptly to avoid slowing down the round). 

Furthermore, minimizing time spent on mulligans respects the group’s pace and keeps the game enjoyable for everyone.

3. Considerations for Fairness and Enjoyment Among Players: 

Fairness is a key part of the mulligan tradition. To avoid overuse, limit mulligans to once or twice per round and agree on these limitations with your group beforehand. Using mulligans sparingly ensures everyone can have fun without compromising the game’s challenge. 

Additionally, consider the skill levels of everyone in the group(a casual use of mulligans can be helpful for beginners), while more experienced players may prefer fewer do-overs to maintain the integrity of the game.

By following these etiquette tips, you can ensure that mulligans enhance the enjoyment of the game while still respecting the spirit of golf.

Common Misconceptions about Mulligans

Mulligans are widely used and enjoyed in casual golf, but there are several common misconceptions surrounding them. Here are some key clarifications:

1. Mulligans Are Not Part of Official Golf Rules: 

One of the biggest misconceptions is that mulligans are an accepted part of golf’s official rulebook. 

However, mulligans are entirely informal and not recognized by governing bodies like the USGA or R&A. In any sanctioned or competitive event, every shot counts, and there are no do-overs. 

For this reason, players should be clear that mulligans are solely for casual play and cannot be expected in competitive settings.

2. Differences Between Casual Play and Competitive Standards: 

Another misconception is that if mulligans are common in casual rounds, they might somehow apply in all golfing contexts. This is not the case. While mulligans can add flexibility and fun among friends, competitive golf adheres strictly to official rules. 

Furthermore, competitions prioritize fairness and accuracy, so every shot(no matter how poor) must be counted. Understanding this distinction helps players transition smoothly between casual and competitive rounds, knowing when they can use mulligans and when they need to play strictly by the rules.

By recognizing these misconceptions, players can enjoy mulligans in casual rounds without expecting them to apply in formal play, preserving the integrity of both settings.

Final Thoughts 

Mulligans add a unique blend of leniency and enjoyment to the game of golf, especially in casual settings. While not part of official rules, these “do-over” shots allow players to recover from mistakes without penalty, often relieving the pressure for beginners or those out to have a relaxed round. 

Therefore, having a good understanding of when and how to use a mulligan, as well as following agreed-upon limitations and proper etiquette, can ensure a fair and enjoyable experience for everyone involved. By respecting these informal guidelines and recognizing the distinction between casual and competitive play, players can incorporate mulligans effectively without compromising the spirit of the game. 

In the end, mulligans exemplify the forgiving and social side of golf, making it accessible and fun for players of all levels.

Key Takeaways

• A mulligan is an informal “do-over” in golf, allowing a player to replay a shot without penalty in casual play.
• Mulligans are not recognized by official golf rules and are strictly used in informal or friendly games.
• Mulligans are common in casual rounds but never allowed in competitive or sanctioned events, where every shot must count.
• The term “mulligan” has several origin theories, with stories linking it to golfers like David Mulligan and Buddy Mulligan in the 1920s and 1930s.
• Players usually agree beforehand on the number and timing of mulligans, often limiting them to one or two per round.
• Common types include the “must mulligan,” a mandatory retake, and the “provisional mulligan,” allowing players to choose the better of two shots.
• Mulligans are typically reserved for the first tee (“breakfast ball”), severely poor shots, or disruptions, but should be used sparingly.
• Communicate with playing partners, take the shot promptly to maintain pace, and respect fairness by keeping mulligans to a minimum.
• A common misconception is that mulligans are part of golf’s official rules, but they are strictly for casual, not competitive, rounds.
• Mulligans can add fun to the game, especially for beginners, but using them judiciously ensures that the game remains fair and enjoyable for all players.

FAQs