Skip to content 
Golf is known for quiet galleries, careful concentration and strict etiquette. The Onion turns that tradition upside down with a fictional announcement suggesting that golf will be loud, creating an absurd vision of professional golf that looks more like a football stadium than a traditional tournament. The supposed change as a serious decision by golf’s governing establishment. Rather than treating the idea as an obvious joke, The Onion uses the language and tone of conventional sports journalism to make the fictional announcement sound believable.
Why Golf Will Be Loud Is the Joke
The central joke works because professional golf has traditionally depended on silence. When a player prepares to hit a shot, spectators are generally expected to stop talking and avoid unnecessary movement. The quiet atmosphere allows players to concentrate and gives important shots a dramatic sense of anticipation. The Onion reverses that familiar experience. In its fictional world, golf will be loud, meaning spectators would no longer be expected to remain silent while players address the ball. That immediately creates a series of ridiculous possibilities.
Imagine a golfer standing over a crucial putt while thousands of spectators cheer, shout and celebrate. Instead of hearing the familiar request for silence, tournament officials might encourage the crowd to become even louder. The contrast is what makes the premise funny. Golf is often associated with patience and restraint, while many other professional sports actively encourage spectators to create as much noise as possible.
A Completely Different Golf Atmosphere
If golf will be loud, the atmosphere at a professional tournament would change dramatically. Spectators could theoretically react to every drive, approach shot and putt with the enthusiasm normally seen at major stadium events. A long drive might receive a huge roar from the gallery. A missed putt could produce an equally dramatic reaction. Players would have to perform in an environment that bears little resemblance to the traditional golf course.
The Onion exaggerates this possibility for comic effect. The fictional policy is not presented as a small adjustment to tournament etiquette. Instead, it becomes a sweeping transformation of the sport. That exaggeration is central to The Onion’s style. The publication frequently takes an ordinary institution and introduces one ridiculous change, then reports on that change as though it were a serious news development.
The Onion’s Deadpan Approach
The humor becomes stronger because the story does not rely on an obvious punchline. Instead, it uses a straight-faced news format. The supposed decision that golf will be loud is treated with the seriousness normally associated with major changes in professional sports. That deadpan approach allows readers to recognize the absurdity themselves.
It also plays with the formal language commonly used by large sports organizations. A simple change in crowd behavior is presented as though it were a major institutional development requiring careful consideration. The result is a familiar Onion formula: take something recognizable, change one fundamental feature and then explore the consequences as seriously as possible.
What Would Noisy Golf Look Like?
The fictional change becomes particularly amusing when applied to situations that normally require complete concentration. A golfer attempting a difficult putt could suddenly face cheering spectators. A player preparing for a tournament-winning shot might hear chants from the crowd rather than silence. Even the traditional request for spectators to remain quiet would become unnecessary.
The idea that golf will be loud also changes the role of spectators. Instead of quietly following players around the course, fans could become active participants in the atmosphere. That would make golf feel closer to sports where crowd noise is part of the experience. The contrast between those environments and traditional golf is the heart of the satire.
Is the PGA Really Making Golf Loud?
No. The announcement described in The Onion’s article is a fictional satirical premise, not a genuine PGA Tour policy announcement. Readers should therefore not interpret the story as breaking sports news. The article is designed to parody the conventions of news reporting while making fun of golf’s famously quiet spectator culture.
The fictional announcement that golf will be loud works because readers already understand how unusual that would be. Without the sport’s longstanding association with silence, the joke would lose much of its impact.
Why the Satire Works
The story ultimately depends on a simple reversal. Golf has rules, customs and traditions that encourage a controlled atmosphere. The Onion imagines what would happen if one of those traditions were suddenly abandoned. The result is an entertaining thought experiment in which professional golfers would have to perform while surrounded by the kind of crowd noise associated with major stadium sports.
There is therefore less about changing golf and more about highlighting what makes golf distinctive. By suggesting that golf will be loud, The Onion reminds readers just how unusual the sport’s traditional silence can seem when compared with other forms of professional entertainment. For golf fans, the humor comes from imagining familiar tournaments under completely unfamiliar circumstances. Players still have to hit precise shots, but the peaceful surroundings have supposedly disappeared.
The fictional announcement turns a minor aspect of golf etiquette into a major sporting revolution. That exaggerated contrast between tradition and chaos is what gives the Onion article its comedic appeal. Ultimately, golf will be loud is not a real prediction or PGA policy. It is a deliberately ridiculous premise built around one of golf’s most recognizable characteristics: the expectation that everyone should keep quiet when the player is about to swing.
